discord-alternatives-wishlist

A community driven comparison and wishlist of features for an ideal privacy-first client to provide an alternative to Discord

PythonCC0-1.033341 open issues
Created Feb 17, 2026Last commit Feb 24, 2026Last human commit Feb 24, 2026
Embed Badge
Play on Codakey
Markdown
[![Play on Codakey](https://codakey.io/badge.svg)](https://codakey.io/projects/discord-alternatives-wishlist)
HTML
<a href="https://codakey.io/projects/discord-alternatives-wishlist"><img src="https://codakey.io/badge.svg" alt="Play on Codakey" height="28" /></a>

Daily Activity

Monthly Activity

Star History

README

Discord Alternatives Comparison

A community-driven comparison of privacy-respecting, open-source chat platforms

Are you a Discord refugee? In February 2026, Discord announced mandatory age verification (face scans or government ID) just 5 months after a breach exposed 70,000 IDs. This project helps you find privacy-respecting alternatives.


📖 Navigation

Main Documentation

Reference


Quick Start

If you want...

GoalTryWhy
Easiest Discord transitionFluxer or Matrix (Commet)Fluxer: Discord-like, self-hostable (⚠️ no E2EE by design). Commet: Discord UI on proven Matrix protocol
True decentralizationMatrix (Element/Commet/Cinny)Federated — no single company controls it, proven at scale
Best for small communities (<100)Fluxer, Spacebar, or MatrixDiscord-like features, self-hostable, privacy-focused
Best for large communities (100+)Matrix, Zulip, or DiscourseProven at scale, topic-based threading, strong moderation
Maximum privacy (E2EE)Signal or MatrixSignal: E2EE by default, gold standard. Matrix: E2EE + federated
Discord bot compatibilitySpacebarDiscord API compatible, existing bots work (⚠️ voice/video experimental)
Gaming voice chatMumble or TeamSpeak⚠️ Neither has E2EE but both reliable. Mumble: open source. TeamSpeak: established.
Self-host without hassleZulip, Rocket.Chat, or ConduitGood docs, Docker support. Conduit: lightweight Matrix server

E2EE Reality Check:

  • Full E2EE: Signal (all messages), Element/Matrix (all messages)
  • ⚠️ Partial E2EE: Telegram (opt-in Secret Chats only), Rocket.Chat (beta, limited)
  • No E2EE: Discord, Fluxer, Spacebar, Zulip, Mattermost, TeamSpeak, Mumble

→ See RESOURCES.md for platform documentation and sources

Avoid Stoat (formerly Revolt): Serious child safety concerns (mishandled CSAM reports), censorship of criticism, deceptive user count claims (advertises "1M+ users" but 200-400 actually online), moving away from open source. Voice features recently added (Feb 18-20, 2026) but very new and stability unproven. See platform notes in COMPARISON.md for details.

→ See COMPARISON.md for full feature comparison


Critical Warnings

Before choosing a platform, check these:

Discord Age Verification (March 2026)

New: Discord is rolling out teen-by-default settings globally starting March 2026:

  • All users defaulted to teen restrictions unless verified as adults
  • Age verification via AI inference, face scan, OR government ID upload
  • Required for age-restricted content and certain settings
  • Most users will be auto-verified via AI, but some will need manual verification
  • Privacy concerns: October 2025 data breach exposed 70,000 IDs
  • New vendor: K-ID (replacing previous breach-affected vendor)

No E2EE: Discord has never had end-to-end encryption. All messages can be read by Discord.

→ See RESOURCES.md for source documentation

Matrix Cryptographic Vulnerability (Feb 17, 2026)

Monitor for patches before using for sensitive communications:

  • Matrix Rust library (vodozemac) has cryptographic issues
  • Affects: Element, Commet, FluffyChat, all Matrix clients using vodozemac
  • See SECURITY.md for latest status

Early Stage / Unverified Platforms

16 platforms are marked "Early Stage / Unverified" - included for transparency but NOT recommended for production use.

Platforms with active security issues:

  • Kloak - Security breach (Feb 20, 2026): Attacker accessed user list and private messages
  • Paracord - 20+ documented vulnerabilities including remote code execution and plaintext secrets

See SECURITY.md for complete vulnerability details.

Other platforms in this category: Ripcord (new), sadlounge, Apoka, Pulse Chat, Sharkord, Roomy, Colanode, Raven, Commz, Voltage, Osmium, Concord, Nexus Chat, Nexus (Magnimont)

These range from vaporware (waitlist only) to very early projects with minimal documentation. Check their notes in COMPARISON.md for specific details on each platform's status and concerns.

AI-Generated "Vibe-Coded" Platforms

  • Paracord, Blite Chat, Voltage — AI-generated, unverified security
  • Discourse, Virola, Osmium, Rocket.Chat, Root — Community flagged concerns
  • Stoat, Fluxer, Oldcord, Spacebar, Zulip — Responsible AI use (transparent, reviewed)

→ See SECURITY.md for explanation

Privacy-Invasive Platforms

  • Discord (March 2026) — Will require face scans or government ID
  • All centralized commercial platforms — Will face same pressure eventually

→ See MODERATION.md for why this matters


What Is This?

This repository is a structured, community-maintained comparison of Discord alternatives:

  • 79 platforms tracked across 9 categories
  • 61 features organized into 8 logical groups
  • Auto-generated comparison tables from single source of truth (platforms.json)

Categories

Matrix Clients (5) — Element, Cinny, Commet, FluffyChat, SchildiChat
Privacy-Focused Centralized (12) — Stoat, Valour, Nerimity, Kloak, Echoed, Voltage, Apoka, Session, RetroShare, 0xchat, etc.
Self-Hosted Platforms (21) — Spacebar, Fluxer, Zulip, Rocket.Chat, Discourse, Mattermost, Strafe, Common Ground, Conduit, etc.
Commercial Alternatives (6) — Discord, Telegram, GameVox, Steam Chat, Osmium, Root
Legacy & Niche (14) — TeamSpeak, Mumble, Signal, Ventrilo, IRC, XMPP, Carrion (Adult RP), etc.
Business Productivity (6) — Slack, Microsoft Teams, Amazon Chime, Pumble, Chanty, Virola
Protocols & Frameworks (1) — Polyproto (for developers, not end users)
Discontinued (8) — Guilded, Xfire, RaidCall, Curse Voice, etc.

→ See COMPARISON.md for detailed breakdown


Most Discord-Like Platforms

Based on feature coverage, real-world testing (mvh, discordless.com), and UI/UX similarity:

RankPlatformWhy Discord-LikeCategoryReality Check
1FluxerNearly complete feature parity, Discord-style UI, bot APISelf-HostedPublic beta, self-hostable
2CommetDiscord-like UI on Matrix protocol, full featuresMatrixSingle maintainer, federated
3ElementFull Matrix features, most mature clientMatrixDifferent UI, proven at scale
4SchildiChatElement fork with Discord-inspired tweaksMatrixElement features + better UX
5SpacebarDiscord API compatible, bot compatibilitySelf-HostedAlpha stage, voice in development
6StoatClosest Discord clone in look/feelPrivacy-Focused⚠️ Alpha: voice broken, slow updates, expect issues
7Rocket.ChatEnterprise features, voice/video, rolesSelf-Hosted50 user limit (free), business-focused
8MattermostTeam chat, moderation, integrationsSelf-HostedDevOps/business focused
9TelegramMassive scale, channels, botsCommercialMissing persistent voice channels
10ZulipTopic-based threading, full featuresSelf-HostedDifferent paradigm (topics required)
11SlackWorkplace standard, strong featuresBusinessBusiness-focused, expensive

⚠️ Alpha/Early Stage Platforms:

  • Stoat — Voice support just added (Feb 18-20, 2026), working on main instance but very new. Browser-based voice functional, desktop app still in development. Updates slow, alpha-quality stability. Beautiful Discord-like UI but production readiness questionable. Serious moderation concerns (see platform notes). Revisit in ~1 year.
  • Spacebar — Discord bot compatibility promising but voice/video still in development. Making new guilds/adding friends may not work consistently.

❌ DO NOT USE (Security Issues):

  • Kloak — Critical security breach (Feb 2026), user data compromised
  • Paracord — 20+ vulnerabilities, vibe-coded, unverified security

Key insights:

  • Fluxer leads for open-source Discord-like experience (discordless: "only open-source app with almost all Discord features")
  • Matrix clients offer proven federation + E2EE, but need moderation bots (Draupnir essential)
  • Stoat looks most like Discord but core features broken — beautiful UI, frustrating experience
  • Avoid platforms with security incidents (Kloak, Paracord) entirely

→ See COMPARISON.md for detailed feature breakdown


Why People Are Leaving Discord

The Timeline:

  • Sept 2025: Discord breach exposes 70,000 government IDs
  • Feb 2026: Discord announces mandatory global age verification
  • March 2026: Phased rollout begins

The Requirements:

  • Face scanning via video selfie, OR
  • Government ID upload (driver's license, passport)
  • "Age inference" AI surveillance in background

The Response:

  • Major creators refuse (Eret: 1M+ followers, Tubbo: 5.2M)
  • Reddit exodus, Nitro cancellations
  • EFF condemns: "Beyond what any law requires"
  • Search spike for "Discord alternatives"

The Deeper Problem:

  • UK Online Safety Act requires platforms to implement age verification
  • EU DSA, Australia, US states — similar laws spreading
  • Any centralized platform will face same pressure
  • Vendor concerns: Discord tested Persona (security issues, tracks extensive metrics for advertisers), switched to k-ID, could switch again
  • Business model shift: Discord increasingly advertiser-friendly, in-app game microtransactions, potential IPO
  • Only solution: Decentralization and self-hosting

→ Read full story: BACKGROUND.md
→ Understand the pattern: MODERATION.md


Feature Groups

All 61 features organized into 8 groups:

  1. Privacy & Licensing (11) — Open source, E2EE, no tracking, AI usage
  2. Pricing (6) — Free tier, hardware costs, premium limitations
  3. Platform Support (8) — Web, Windows, macOS, Linux, Android, iOS, Docker
  4. Communication (10) — Voice, video, screen sharing, text, files
  5. Moderation & Safety (8) — AutoMod, audit logs, raid protection, age/ID verification
  6. Server & Admin (7) — Roles, organization, migration, bridges
  7. Channels & Content (5) — Docs, events, galleries, announcements
  8. Community Tools (6) — Bots, webhooks, raid planners, tournaments

→ See FEATURES.md for detailed explanations and trade-offs


How to Choose

Step 1: Define Your Must-Haves

  • What features can't you live without?
  • What's your privacy tolerance?
  • What's your technical skill level?
  • What's your budget?

Step 2: Check Security

  • Read SECURITY.md for active incidents
  • Avoid vibe-coded platforms for privacy-critical use
  • Prefer established, audited platforms

Step 3: Consider Moderation Needs

  • Small community (<500)? Basic tools sufficient
  • Large community (1000+)? Need AutoMod, audit logs
  • Privacy-focused? Avoid invasive verification

Step 4: Review Comparison

  • Browse COMPARISON.md
  • Check platform notes (marked with †)
  • Compare options side-by-side

Step 5: Test Before Committing

  • Try platform before migrating
  • Test with small group
  • Verify critical features work

→ See FEATURES.md for prioritization guidance


Contributing

We welcome contributions! Here's how to help:

Report Inaccuracies

  • Open an Issue with label correction
  • Or submit PR updating platforms.json

Add New Platform

  1. Check it's not already listed
  2. Ensure platform is real (not vaporware)
  3. Follow template in platforms.json
  4. See CONTRIBUTING.md for guidelines

Vote on Features

  • Visit Discussions
  • Upvote features you want tracked
  • Suggest new features (use template)

Share Your Experience

  • Migrated a community? Tell us what worked
  • Found inaccuracies? Let us know
  • Security concerns? Please report

→ See CONTRIBUTING.md for full guidelines


Data Sources

Primary source: platforms.json — single source of truth

Sources include:

  • Official GitHub repositories and documentation
  • Security audits and vulnerability reports
  • Recent news articles and press releases
  • Community testing and feedback

→ See RESOURCES.md for detailed sources by platform

Feature values:

  • yes — Fully supported
  • ⚠️ partial — Limited support
  • 🗓️ planned — On roadmap
  • no — Not supported
  • unknown — Unverified

License

Creative Commons Zero v1.0 Universal (CC0) — freely usable by anyone.


Built by the community, for the community.
If this helped you, consider starring ⭐ the repo so others can find it.

Related Projects